Monthly Archives: June 2009

A Livelihood Can Be a Life

Posted on by Bill Ryan

I’m going to start this piece off by stating something that for some readers may be too obvious, but which I think is worth saying anyway. There is a big difference between searching for a job and searching for a career.

For the sake of simplicity, I see a job as something you do for money, whereas a career is something you do to give meaning and purpose to life. Many of you may be perfectly content separating livelihood from living and see a job merely as a means to a financial end. Living, for those of this mindset, consists of contentment found in mainly choosing things and experiences that make life interesting and stimulating. Together they make up a life that is at a minimum, good enough. Getting paid for being sufficiently stimulated, by whatever means, appears to be the primary goal. Money is generally necessary for this kind of lifestyle and therefore getting and keeping a job that pays decently becomes important. Fine. It is a perfectly conventional viewpoint about work. And one I don’t recommend. 

Work in a capitalist democracy such as ours displays its greatest value not in just how productive the society becomes, but in how everyone has the potential to express their unique contribution to both the greater good and to themselves. I do not see a benefit in drawing too sharp a distinction between living and work. I am alright with thinking that what you are is what you do. Now, some of you may think this sounds like a workaholic Boomer talking, who has not yet learned how to chill. Perhaps. Rather, I am suggesting that integrating work and life, career and self, can result in a fuller sense of being and completeness. 

It is good to have an identity. It is of value to see yourself and to have others see you as comprised of those significant elements of our lives, be they family member, citizen, leisure-lover, or worker. To define yourself in terms that exclude or downplay your work and how you spend such a large amount of time and energy denies yourself much of the richness you could be feeling from life. 

I am impressed by people who know something very well, be it a skill or body of knowledge. These people enjoy sharing their expertise through reaching out and teaching others or by making available the products and services they can craft expertly. To develop a talent to the point in which you are an artisan means you can be living a great life. You have meaning and purpose. You give yourself a gift beyond what money alone can provide. 

It is easy to blame our employer or simple circumstances for our despair with work. Having each week be a countdown to the weekend starting with a Blue Monday is sad. If you associate Wednesday with Hump Day, then your career is not on track. It’s not working for you.

Take time to reflect on what you are doing. Are you just working or are you living? Life does not have to be just getting by or getting through it. You can have a relationship with yourself that is highlighted by growth and mastery. You can be somebody and your work can be a big satisfying part of who you are. 

Despite the current Recession, this is a great time to form a career in America. We are not as constricted by class, family legacy, race, or gender roles as we once were or as is still the case in many parts of the world. Here, a true meritocracy is coming about. [Update: In the years since I wrote this paragraph, I have become more aware of how gender roles and meritocracy can lack fairness. I address this issue in future essays.] 

The upcoming years should be open to entrepreneurial solutions and our collective value propositions. Now is the time to find your place and to carve out your niche. Do not let the difficulty of shifting to this way of thinking hold you back. Enjoy the congruence of livelihood and life. You can be happier than you ever thought possible.

Beware of Too Much Education

Posted on by Bill Ryan

I am a big fan of education… particularly college education. I used to think when I was in my twenties that I could easily have become a professional student. And if it hadn’t been for getting married and becoming a parent, I would have. Even now, many years later, I can still feel the nerdy thrill of taking classes and planning degree work.

I was also a teacher for thirty-one years and would encourage students any chance that I got for them to pursue post-secondary education, if they wanted to increase their chances of finding satisfying work at a decent salary. I would cite statistics showing that a college education could on average double their lifetime earnings compared to someone with only a high school education. My faith in the power of higher education remains unshaken. I think nearly everyone should continue formal education for as long as possible.

However, I have seen a troubling downside to acquiring too much college education. In a word, it is debt. It is not unusual to run across thirty-somethings and others who have multiple degrees and/or certifications and no satisfying employment. What they do have, though, are thousands of dollars owed for the education received to get those degrees and certs. I’ve heard staggering figures. There are relatively young people who are looking at decades of school loan payback ahead of them. This restricts their lifestyles, as all debt does, and makes further education appear impossible to achieve.

Now, it would be one thing if the folks I’m talking about had exciting, stimulating careers paying them robust salaries. But too often this is not the case. Instead, they are settling for second rate job choices and realizing as they approach middle age that they are not happy career-wise, leaving them feeling stuck.

How did this happen? It is what can occur if you do not enter higher education with at least the beginning of a career plan. Everyone has heard the story that a college education opens doors and leads to career success. And as I indicated earlier, there is much evidence that it can. But it is far from a guarantee. A college degree should not be thought of as a magic bullet. If years spent at a university are not a well thought through means to an end, then it can be a costly waste of time.

A typical sequence is this — you are a student who majors in some undergraduate program for weak reasons, generally because you were without enough quality guidance. Afterwards, you find yourself in a ho-hum job and think that the way out is to go back to school to get another degree. You hope that this time it will “work”.

But your decision making again has not been monitored by someone who can properly assist you. So, you find yourself again in a less than stellar job and think that if you had only followed your heart the first time you would not be in this mess. So, you go back to school to study your passion, incur more debt, and realize a gazillion dollars later that you are still not happy. 

Career planning should begin very early in a student’s education, whether it is done by a parent, a guidance counselor, a teacher, or a privately hired career development specialist. Basically, someone who actually has time, interest, and perspective to focus on you. College costs way too much to have the experience squandered. However, properly directed higher education can help lead to meaningful and sustained careers.

I recommend taking the time to think through what you hope to achieve from education and process these thoughts, along with crucial elements of your personality, in the presence of a career professional.  It is worth the effort and money to do this one right.

The Forward Leaning Consultant

Posted on by Bill Ryan

In my last blog, I suggested that we Americans may not be as entrepreneurial as we think we are when it comes to getting or staying employed, particularly during a Recession like this one. My observation is that we continue to heavily rely on open positions to fill rather than trying to create our own marketable situations.

For many young and middle-aged workers, it’s easier to understand the greater need for security and the steady paycheck given that they are raising families and building wealth. For them, free-lancing may indeed carry too much risk. But for the seasoned older professional worker with accumulated wisdom and experience, I find it a bit odd that far too many continue to seek a job offered and defined by someone else.

Now, if you’re happy with a work life following someone else’s job description, because it lightens the mental and emotional load you need to carry, then fine. For those of you, however, who have been around the block a few times and have formed confident opinions and positions about how your industry can best function, then you may want to codify those ideas into proposals that you present to managers in need of solutions.

I believe there comes a point in many professionals’  lives when you reach a level of maturity and sophistication, which prepares you for analyzing the known workplace with the intent of discovering and offering remedies to common or unique problems. This approach can form the backbone of your “job search”. Don’t just look for a job, look for innovative methods and protocols that add value to the workplace and propose them to organizations in search of these solutions.

The notion that becoming a consultant is reserved only for the gutsy cream-of-the-crop type is old fashioned. To the dismay of unions and traditionalists, we are becoming a freelance nation. It is true many workplaces are still traditional in how they source talent, but there is ample evidence that this is changing. More and more Human Resource departments are becoming used to searching for outsourced talent that reduces their costs while offering more targeted impact on production. The actual implementation lies in how well you unravel issues, advance answers, brand yourself, and negotiate an arrangement with an organization that needs you.

So, my suggestion is to use the time you usually spend searching through Monster and CareerBuilder to systematically build cases that you can confidently present. Your time will be better spent, and you get the added benefit of imposing professional development on yourself.

You probably already know the standard means of writing proposals within your industry. If you don’t know, find out. From there, apply marketing principles, especially personal branding, that assist you in reaching the audiences who need to hear from you. And go for it.

Might this style of employment search be too cowboy oriented. Perhaps. But, what’s the downside? At least you leaned forward into your employment status, acted, organized yourself, and learned some things. Is that such a bad way to spend time finding work?